Home > English > Latin America and the Caribbean > MEXICO - Legal Abortion No Longer a Distant Goal for Activists

MEXICO - Legal Abortion No Longer a Distant Goal for Activists

Diego Cevallos, IPS

Monday 26 March 2007, posted by Manuela Garza Ascencio

IPS - Mexico could join Cuba and Guyana as the only countries in Latin America where abortion is legal in cases other than those involving rape or a threat to a pregnant woman’s life.

Two draft laws apparently enjoy majority support, and the Church and conservative groups are up in arms.

For the first time "there is a serious, mature debate on this, and a strong possibility that abortion will be decriminalised, which would be a very positive step in terms of the rights of women," Martha Júarez, spokeswoman for the non-governmental Information Group on Reproductive Choice (GIRE), told IPS.

Last week, opposition legislators from the leftist Democratic Revolution Party (PRD), the centrist Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI), and the small Alternativa party introduced a draft law in the Mexico City legislature that would allow voluntary abortion to be carried out in the city up to the 14th week of pregnancy.

And on Tuesday, PRD senators presented a draft law in Congress that would make abortion legal nationwide before the 12th week of pregnancy.

"It does look very likely that these draft laws will be approved, which would be appalling, because it would legalise the murder of defenceless beings," Jorge Serrano, director of the anti-abortion Comité Pro Vida (Pro-Life Committee), commented to IPS.

"We are not against women’s rights, but what rights are we talking about if abortion is a crime, in every sense of the word," he argued.

The conservative governing National Action Party (PAN), which does not hold a majority in the city legislature or the national Congress, announced protest demonstrations and legal action aimed at blocking the two draft laws, while President Felipe Calderón urged lawmakers to handle the issue "with great care."

Calderón said he would respect the decisions reached by the legislators. But he clarified that he believes in "the defence of life" and considers the present legislation, which allows — in most Mexican states — abortion only in case of rape, a deformed fetus, or a threat to the life of the pregnant woman, adequate "for now."

Of the 193 United Nations member countries, 188 allow therapeutic abortion in order to save the woman’s life. Only in Chile, El Salvador, Honduras, Nicaragua and the Vatican is abortion illegal under any circumstance, according to the World Health Organisation (WHO).

In Latin America and the Caribbean, women’s groups and activists are fighting for the legalisation of abortion in nearly every country.

A study by the Autonomous National University of Mexico estimated that up to one million illegal abortions a year — equivalent to 30 percent of all pregnancies — are practiced in this country of 103 million people.

Other studies have reported that backstreet abortions are the fourth or fifth leading cause of death among Mexican women, and that even in cases of rape, deformed fetuses or risk to the mother’s life, obtaining permission for a legal abortion is nearly impossible.

A survey carried out last year by the National Institute of Statistics found that only 15 percent of the pregnant women interviewed said they really wanted to be having a baby at that time.

The Vatican announced that it was sending Colombian Bishop Alfonso López, president of the Pontifical Council for the Family, to Mexico to support opponents of the new draft laws.

Conservatives have dredged up their standard arguments claiming that abortion is murder. They have taken out advertising space in the local press to explain in detail what abortion methods consist of and to point out that at a few weeks’ gestation, the fetus already has a fully human form.

Furthermore, the Coalition for the Rights of All has put videos on the Internet showing how a fetus dies when a woman has an abortion.

GIRE’s Juárez said that conservatives are using the "sensationalist strategy of broadcasting old videos" to oppose the draft laws. She said that if they had "a minimum of integrity" they ought to make available other videos showing the deaths of women who have undergone unsafe backstreet abortions.

An estimated four million abortions a year are practiced in Latin America, and 5,000 women die as a result, according to the WHO. Thirty to 40 percent of women who go through the procedure suffer life-threatening complications.

"Deciding whether or not to have a child should be exclusively the woman’s choice. That is her right, and she should not have to put her life at risk for it," Juárez said.

"It is not our point of view that abortion should become a general practice. The important thing is to have a public health system that improves and extends everything to do with sex education and prevention of unwanted pregnancies," she said.

The draft laws under debate in Mexico stress that access to contraceptive methods needs to be improved urgently.

Juárez said that "in the present legislative process we found maturity and an openness to listen to different points of view, and a clear resistance to the threats and warnings from the church and conservatives, which is a reason to celebrate."

But Serrano of the Comité Pro Vida said that failure to listen to the Church, which is threatening to excommunicate those who are in favour of legalised abortion, would be a major error. In his opinion, the Church is only defending the life and dignity of human beings, and "no one should be opposed to that."

The debate includes the timeworn discussion about whether a fetus at less than 12 or 14 weeks gestation should be considered an individual person or not, and whether or not it feels pain when it is aborted.

Alfonso Gutiérrez, a Mexican doctor who specialises in assisted reproduction and owns several clinics, said that the fetal nervous system starts functioning from the seventh week of gestation, "but I can’t say for sure that it can already feel."

"What I do say is that abortion destroys a potential person," he said.


The opinions expressed herein in the articles and comments are those of their authors and do not necessarily reflect those of AlterInfos. Insulting or injurious comments will be deleted without previous notice. AlterInfos is a pluralist media with a sensibility leaning toward the left. It tries to echo emancipatory projects and struggles. Comments oriented towards the opposite direction will not be published here, but they will surely find another space on the web to do so.

Forum posts

  • The tone of your article indicates the author supports legalizing abortion in Mexico. For that, the entire newspaper staff should be ashamed of themselves.

    It is very simple; ¡ABORTION IS MURDER!

    As if Mexico did not have enough problems, you and your ilk want to bring down the wrath of Almighty God by encouraging Mexicans to kill their own children.

    The two positive things Mexicans are famous for - and correctly so - is the love they have for children, and the value they put on the family. And now you want them to abandon these things in order to move toward some debased secular humanist society that you and other atheistic socialists like you want to create.

    Instead of murdering the babies of poor people and undermining the morals of society, why do you not try to help the people of Mexico?

    You and your kind are truly diabolical.

    View online : abortion

    • El tono de tu artículo indica del autor aproba la legalizan el aborto en México. Para eso, el personal entero del periódico debe estar avergonzado de sí mismos.

      Es muy simple; ¡EL ABORTO ES ASESINATO! Como si México no tuviera bastantes problemas, tú y tu socios desean traer abajo la cólera del dios todopoderoso animando a mexicano que mate a sus propios niños.

      Los mexicanos son famoso por dos cosas es famoso - y correctamente así - es el amor que tienen para los niños, y el valor ponen encendido a familia. Y ahora quisieras que abandonaran estas cosas para moverse hacia una cierta sociedad secular rebajada del humanista a que tú y otros socialistas ateos como ti deseen crear.

      ¿Por que quieres asesinar a los bebés de la gente pobre y destruir las moralejas de la sociedad; por qué no intentas ayudar a la gente de México?

      Tú y tu clase son verdad diabólicos.

Any message or comments?


This forum is moderated before publication: your contribution will only appear after being validated by an administrator.

Who are you?
Your post

To create paragraphs, just leave blank lines.